Monday, November 30, 2020

Luxury Retailers Enter E-Commerce

 For this week's blog post, I read an article on how luxury brands are trying to enter e-commerce. This has been a trend for the past few years, but accelerated by the pandemic. Historically, luxury retailers have been hesitant to sell their goods online, mainly due to fear of counterfeit goods. Most have avoided partnerships with Amazon, as the site is known for carrying everything and may give the wrong impression of the luxury brands.

Today, Amazon and other companies such as Farfetch are competing to carry luxury brands online. To assuage the concerns of the luxury retailers, they have given control of the digital storefront to the manufacturers and enforced tighter controls to limit the sales of counterfeit items. Some brands have tried moving online without a partner, but few have been able to find success without partnering with an existing online powerhouse such as Amazon. To date, Alibaba and Amazon are the strongest players in the East and West, respectively, and the two are racing to become the dominant player in the segment.

As international travel has been restricted, many consumers are now shopping for luxury goods online rather than visiting brick and mortar luxury retailers abroad. While the restrictions on travel may be lifted next year with the release of vaccines, luxury retailers are showing a long term commitment to the digital channel as they have seen promising results in the past year. 

This article drew my attention as I wondered what goods can't or typically aren't purchased online. Just a few years ago, it would be strange to purchase a car online, but Tesla and other companies have found success using the online model. I think it's interesting to see luxury retailers begin to embrace the digital sales channel as well after realizing that they can fight the issue of counterfeit goods and still control their brand image while partnering with major online retailers.

Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/29/business/amazon-farfetch-richemont-ecommerce-wars.html

Chatbots Can Be Used Throughout the Marketing Funnel

Chatbots are an emerging form of digital marketing with a wide variety of applications. Some key benefits of a chatbot include 24/7 availability and automation of responses to the most common customer inquiries. 

A chatbot can be used throughout the marketing funnel: 

1. Awareness - Chatbots can be used to enhance or augment customer awareness. For example, a chatbot can direct a customer to personalized, popular, or sale items on your website. 

2. Interest - When a potential customer is interested, they typically seek additional information with which they can use to make their purchase. A chatbot can directly provide or link to commonly used decision-making information such as customer reviews, warranties & guarantees, or pricing information.

3. Decision - Chatbots can be used to actively push interested customers towards a decision point. Chatbots can leverage the visitor's in-site behavior to prioritize and customize decision propositions.

4. Action - Chatbots can reduce friction between the decision-point and point-of sale. Many bots are equipped to perform the transaction right in the chatbot function, and they can also perform upsell and cross-sell functions. 

There are a wide variety of applications for chatbots, and their prominence continues to rise as small-business-friendly and affordable options proliferate across the web. 

For a more detailed readthrough of applications, see the following source article: How to Use Sales Chatbots to Optimize Sales Funnel | Landbot.

Holiday ads nod to COVID-19, but depicting gatherings also works

In an analysis conducted by Ace Metrix, 32% holiday ads were shown to have incorporated COVID-19 themes stressing how this holiday season is different from usual. 

Ace Metrix determined that campaigns which acknowledged the pandemic performed slightly better with viewers, but not significantly so. Including masks in holiday ads also did not make a substantial different in viewers' receptions. This indicates that acknowledging the new normal is likely more important than addressing all the specific details of it. 

The report shows that referencing the pandemic in ads may not be completely necessary despite the pressure companies feel to abide by safety guidelines in these ads. It appears that a majority of viewers did not care or comment on ads showing social gatherings without safety precautions. 

New norms perpetuated by the pandemic, such as curbside pickup, contactless payments, and video calling are also sparsely shown in advertisements. This may have to do with masks not being overwhelmingly popular in the country, as evidenced by the spiking COVID-19 cases. 

Interestingly, animation has taken a larger spotlight in holiday ads due to production challenges caused by the pandemic. 14% of holiday ads this year utilize some form of animation.


Source: https://www.marketingdive.com/news/holiday-ads-nod-to-covid-19-but-depicting-gatherings-also-works-study-fin/589391/

...Why DTC Brands Plan to Use Texting for Black Friday and Cyber Monday This Year

https://digiday.com/marketing/email-has-become-so-cluttered-why-dtc-brands-plan-to-use-texting-for-black-friday-and-cyber-monday-this-year/

Email is a mature marketing channel; however, still a crucial one with consistently high ROI. That said, it is no surprise that most brands use it - and thus, are scared that email inboxes will be too "noisy" - inundated throughout this season's "Cyber-Five" (the period between Thanksgiving and Cyber Monday). In fact, I've read an article claiming that it's the best, most convenient time to unsubscribe. So, marketers are turning to texting, "a channel that is still nascent, but growing rapidly." Still, most brands see texting as an extension of their email strategies. The CEO of Sharma Brands states that "the click-through-rate is around 70% and conversion rate is north of 25%." While these results are promising, experts do note that text messaging is a more personal channel. As mentioned in class, customers are at a higher risk of unsubscribing if communication is too frequent. 

How The Pandemic Has Shifted Mobile Gaming Behaviors Worldwide

 https://www.thinkwithgoogle.com/consumer-insights/consumer-trends/mobile-casual-gaming-trends/


The article breaks up recent, pandemic gaming behaviors into 3 main trends: 

1) Casual Gaming Trends are on the Rise

There is, across the board, an uptick in spending. This can be in the form of in-game spending or purchasing a new game entirely. This presents two opportunities for marketers. Marketers can first focus on acquiring this new "casual" audience at a lower cost. Since 40+ percent of new gamers plan to continue gaming, marketers can also consider cost-per-action (vs. install) to develop more engaged users. 

2) Deeper Engagement and Longer Quests

The author encourages app campaigns to increase engagement - citing King (the maker of Candy Crush) as a prime example. King was able to reengage lapsed users, achieving a better ROI and cost per acquisition.

3) The Power of Power-Ups

Companies can incentivize users to watch video ads with "power-ups and boosters." Over one third of users will engage with the ads receive these incentives - more recently coined as "rewarded interstitials."

And this is just mobile gaming. I'm sure that console gaming (PlayStation, Xbox) has also increased in popularity throughout the pandemic. 

Focusing on value-based marketing in the face of upheaval

 Focusing on value-based marketing in the face of upheaval

Strategic cost optimization is needed now more than ever, in the face of a global pandemic that has prompted corporate leaders to cut budgets affecting marketing spend. 

According to Gartner's 2020 CMO Spend Survey, 44% of CMOs expected an in-year budget cut of more than 5% as a result of COVID-19. Another Gartner poll taken less than two months later reported those expecting a cut of more than 5% had jumped to almost two thirds (59%) of respondents, with the remaining third expecting a cut of at least 15%. 

In light of the above, it is important for leaders to know what to spend on and what not to spend on. There are 3 main mistakes that CMOs make in the COVID-19 era: 

  • Mistake 1: Blanket cuts to in-year budgets with unrealistic targets: 

Most leaders apply blanket cuts that spread across most channels e.g., cut on 20% marketing expenses for the year. The main issue with this type of thinking is that marketing's cost base is varied, with a mix of near-term, variable costs (e.g. media spend), and longer-term commitments (e.g. marketing technology costs). From a practical point of view, it's easier to cut some costs than others and some marketing items deliver higher value than others. Rather than applying blanket cuts, leaders should spend time prioritizing marketing's investment, with the objective of retaining the bundles of resources that yield the greatest ROI, and cutting the costs with the weakest return. This is the basic essence of zero-basing: ranking investments based on their return, and considering if better returns could be achieved through alternative investments.

  • Mistake 2: Choking-off investments in marketing innovation

Because the value of innovation efforts is hard to measure, innovation investments is placed in a precarious position when it comes to budget planning. Based on mistake No. 1 above, if you can't measure it, it's difficult to defend it. However, the answer should not be to cut innovation programs, it should be to find a better way of measuring the impact of innovation programs. But, why is that?

Gartner analysis from the Great Recession found those companies that focused on costs, talent and innovation achieved efficient growth, outperforming their peers in the immediate aftermath of the crisis, but also sustained (and grew) this advantage in the following years. Efficient innovation investment makes good economic sense.

  • Mistake 3: Mistake cost for value when building multichannel budgets

Throughout 2020, Gartner survey data has reported shifts in channel spend e.g., some of the leaders that previously spent heavily on digital channels now shifted to traditional channels and vice versa. But have all these shifts been to the right channel? Are these channel investments being made in the most efficient ways? Evidence from Gartner's Digital IQ analysis, "B2B: How to Maximize the Efficiency of Digital Marketing Assets Amid Budget Scarcity," indicates there are still issues faced by brands. Digital ad spend may have increased, but there's evidence that this spend is not deployed efficiently or with appropriate calls to action. The problem is that very often, channel value is mistaken to channel cost. Even in budget constrained times, channel investments must be driven primarily by their ability to reach the target audience and to move them to the next stage of their journey as cost efficiently as possible.

The above are the key mistakes that CMOs can make during COVID-19, when tackling budget challenge. Getting good at strategic cost optimization ensures that marketing is sustainable in the face of upheaval and it should be part of all marketers' strategic marketing tool kit - whether budgets are climbing or falling - to ultimately lead with a value-based marketing approach.  

Source: https://www.marketingdive.com/news/3-mistakes-cmos-are-making-with-covid-era-budgets/589217/ 

 

TikTok Partners with Shopify on Social Commerce

 https://techcrunch.com/2020/10/27/tiktok-invests-in-social-commerce-via-new-shopify-partnership/


Shopify partners with TikTok- in an effort "to make it easier for Shopify's over 1 million merchants to reach TikTok's younger (highly engaged) audience and drive sales." Merchants will be able to create and run digital marketing campaigns from the Shopify app. While campaign costs will vary, the newly available ad tools will allow merchants to target audiences across demographic characteristics (age, gender, etc.) as well as track the campaign's success (or lack thereof). This is an important opportunity for Shopify as "TikTok is one of the world's fastest growing entertainment platforms." This partnership comes at the right time - as social commerce continues to gain momentum. Competitors, like Instagram, just redesigned its home screen to include a designated "Shop" tab.

'

Sunday, November 29, 2020

Xfinity Ad Reveals the Best Gift from Santa

Amid the craziness of 2020, it is heartening to see a well thought out ad that brings not only the holiday spirit but also a warm message that is meaningful for us all. The latest ad "The Greatest Gift" tells the story of Santa talking to his elves via conference call and encouraging them to think of a better gift for the year. Eventually, one of the elves thought of the idea of packing "togetherness" into the gifts, bringing people the moments that they spend with their families, including grandma's cooking, grandpa's stories, and family snowball fight. Besides the upbeat message, the ad is also "full of all the quirks and annoyances 2020 has brought", including being stuck indoors, spouse walking into the background of video call, and talking on mute. These witty details throughout the short firm really strike a chord for the viewers who have certainly been through a lot in the year, and resonated with the audience on an emotional level. 

This holiday season has certainly been challenging for advertisers who are looking to celebrate the holiday spirit while being cautious with social gatherings and large family reunions. The Xfinity ad certainly did a great job of accomplishing both while building a natural connection with the viewers. It is certainly worth noting for all the marketers out there.


Reference: 

https://www.adweek.com/agencies/frustrated-by-2020-steve-carells-santa-finds-holiday-joy-in-ad-for-xfinity/


2021 Email Marketing Predictions

Recent research reports predict consumers will receive more emails and text messages in 2021 than ever before, as brands try to develop more personal relationships with their customers during the covid-19 pandemic. The report predicts marketing message volume will increase by 40% in 2021. If consumers are not coming into stores, brands need to remain top of mind and relevant. In addition to an unpredictable economy, marketers face another obstacle: a changing data privacy landscape. The report predicts brands will spend more on loyalty and retention, versus identifying new customers.

See here for more predictions about email marketing in 2021.

Seeking for an innovative shopping experience in Japan.

 During this pandemic, most of us hesitate to visit brick- and mortar stores, so it boosts online sales and many department stores have been having a hard time finding new strategy on how to attract customers again.

Let me share the endeavor of one of the biggest Japanese department stores named Isetan Mitsukoshi. They launched a new app which could give customers new a shopping experience.

In this said app, customers can receive product recommendations based on their preference, plus the app can connect customers with their salespeople through videoconference, so they can virtually see the items available in their store.

They set a trend using a hybrid shopping experience of both online and offline, and it may become the standard for the new era.


Source:
Isetan app brings in-store shopping experience online amid pandemic
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2020/11/25/business/corporate-business/isetan-app-coronavirus-shopping/

Comments on Tony Hsieh's Legacy for Marketers

I was devastated to hear the news over the weekend that the legendary entrepreneur Tony Hseih tragically passed away. Tony was best known as the former CEO of Zappos, which he sold to Amazon for $1.1B in July 2009. He made an enormous impact on e-commerce, customer service, and company culture. Marketers can benefit greatly from some lessons from Tony's legacy. Here are a few. To learn more, you can also check out Tony's book, Delivering Happiness. 

#1: Happy employees are critical to gaining happy and satisfied customers 

Tony was a big believer in the value of company culture to deliver long-term business results and the idea that "Your company culture is your brand, and your employees are your brand ambassadors." Based on this idea, Zappos created 10 core values that would guide the employee decision-making process, giving them clear values to work off of. Zappos also provides incredible benefits to all employees and focuses on training them. Employees are given "Zollars" to reward colleagues when they do something in line with the company values. 

#2: Customer service is key for longterm growth 

Zappo's philosophy is "Zappos.com is a service company that just happens to sell shoes." This reinforces their value of providing the best customer service possible. In fact, Zappos gives customer service reps the freedom to make decisions on how to keep customers happy. There's a powerful story of a Zappos customer who returned shoes who were supposed to be for her dad who suddenly based away, so she reached to Zappos to return them. The Zappos customer service rep, on top of creating a seamless return process, sent the customer flowers to express sympathy for her loss. It is believed that this customer became a lifelong customer after this interaction because of the kindness that Zappos treated her with. 

#3: Invest in developing talent

Zappos historically doesn't hire as many experienced workers. Most are hired at an entry-level and then Zappos provides extensive training to help build their skill set with an eye toward Zappos unique culture. This is important because it reinforces the importance of investing in talent and giving talent opportunities, especially in underserved areas (Zappos famously moved their headquarters to Las Vegas). 

Marketers can take a cue from Tony's book and understand the importance of culture for a company's business and brand. I hope that Tony's incredible career and lessons live on. 


Sources:

  • https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/28/obituaries/tony-hsieh-dead.html
  • https://hbr.org/2010/07/how-i-did-it-zapposs-ceo-on-going-to-extremes-for-customers


 What's old is new again in marketing: 

The pandemic has shifted trends, forcing content marketing back into the spotlight instead of the reliance brands put on experiential marketing. The main force of this comes from the generation that will soon takeover to almost half of all consumers, Gen-Z. It seems that just as the world and brands were feeling adjusted to the demands and shifts of millennials, the Gen-Z generation became old enough to have purchasing power. 

However, if content marketing is the key to Gen-Z, I wonder why it is that brands still have such a hard time capturing them as consumers? If you look at different industries, many new brands are emerging as disruptors in the category because they are able to capture the Gen-Z market. In the beauty industry as an example, acne products and solutions have existed for decades. So why is it then that brands like starface and topicals were able to disrupt the acne skincare market and attract so many of these new consumers? 

I don't know if we have an exact science behind it, but the article I included at the end of this link has some good ideas on how to regain their attention through new ways of content marketing. 

A few suggestions were:

1) Video content that has them stop in their tracks

2) Content focused on the benefit and service and not just the product

3) micro influencers or those that feel genuine to the consumer 

The way to win this new consumer, is to speak to them not as a brand and a seller but as a friend building a community. These consumers want to be part of something larger and more important, and their digital native ways allow them to do so. The brands just need to catch up and on. 





https://gulfbusiness.com/generation-z-how-should-brands-target-and-engage-them/

Advertising on the Apple Watch

I was gifted a brand new Apple Watch recently and started thinking about the advertising capabilities of the device. On one hand, the small interface makes advertisements very intrusive and distracting. The ads would need to take up the whole space in order to be even legible. Normal placement methods would not work very well. On the other hand, the device's hyper localization and fitness use cases present a lot of opportunities. The Apple Watch is also connected to the iPhone, which provides a wealth of data to utilize.

To no surprise, a company has already created an application to that enables personalization based on location that has been around since 2015. TapSense makes ads as relevant based on current phone usage metrics and motions on the iPhone to close ads in a non-intrusive way. It seems the company has not been successful, however, with the website down and not much growth since 2015, according to Crunchbase. 

In fact, with Apple's move to limit IDFA data usage on apps such as Facebook for iOS14, it will be even harder to place ads on Apple Watch, since they are both highly connected. The implications of reduced ads both increases user experience, though I think in the short run. No more intrusive ads during normal usage are definitely a plus. In the long term, however, the lack of ads could limit developer incentives to build on the platform, and decrease a potentially lucrative revenue stream. These counteracting forces would keep the Apple Watch in its current niche category of primarily being a fitness device. Maybe that is the intention and for the best? 

Saturday, November 28, 2020

Brands Taking a Stand Against Black Friday Sales

This year, many companies are shying away from traditional Black Friday blowout sales in light of the current circumstances and some are even going as far as discouraging excessive spending. It is a very different message than we’ve seen in the past and serves as a refreshing new approach to brand building with a longer-term view. Some of these companies include Alohas, Allbirds, Bearaby and Patagonia who used the tagline “Buy Less, Demand More” and directed consumers to their used clothing marketplace website in an effort to get customers to reduce waste and pollution. Bearaby took it to the next level by actually making it more difficult for consumers to make purchases on their website by inserting error pages and popups along the consumer’s path to purchase to inspire the consumer to take a step back and shop more mindfully. It will be interesting to see how this plays out in the long run. Will consumers internalize this message or believe that it’s just a marketing ploy? Will it breed enough loyalty and awareness for companies to offset the surge in sales they are potentially missing? Will these companies avoid brand dilution by not offering steep discounts?

https://www.thedrum.com/news/2020/11/27/top-anti-black-friday-campaigns-patagonia-allbirds-more-reject-consumerism

https://www.morningbrew.com/marketing/stories/2020/11/24/bearaby-everlane-among-brands-experimenting-antiblack-friday-messaging-year

Mask-wearing in Commercials: Yes or No?

2020 has been quite the year and the COVID pandemic is still very much a part of our daily lives. Living in NYC, wearing a mask has become a daily necessity and a norm, but this is definitely not the case everywhere in the U.S. If you live in the suburb, you can easily walk outside without seeing another person and not need to wear a mask (and also forget that the pandemic is ongoing). I'm sure we all had a moment sometime this year, when we were watching TV and all of sudden felt weird seeing people in crowded places not wearing a face mask. Once in awhile, an advertisement will also remind us of how things "used to be". 

So the question is, should commercials have people wearing masks? In my opinion, they should. Mask wearing reduces the spread of COVID and having masks in commercials would help reinforce wearing masks as the norm and the right thing to do. However, for companies, the goal of an advertisement is to promote the brand or a specific product and more often than not aims to connect with the consumer emotionally. Consumers don't want to be reminded of the pandemic and want their moods uplifted. It really depends on the context, but ultimately companies need to be responsible for whichever decision they end up choosing. 

Google Improves Ads for Mobile

Source: https://www.blog.google/products/ads/local-ads/

Mobile phones have fundamentally changed many aspects of the world, and marketers have been embracing their importance. Over the past several years, marketers have substantially increased the amount of ad spend allocated to mobile, both on browsers and in apps, in an effort to reach customers on their preferred and most-used device. Also recognizing this trend, Google has made substantive changes to its ad platform on mobile to help marketers reach their goals.

The latest installment from Google includes expanded features to assist retailers in targeted local and shopping campaigns. The local campaigns were designed to drive traffic to nearby store locations by geotargeting mobile users, and the shopping campaigns expanded capabilities for consumers to purchase items online and pick them up in the store. These ads are more seamlessly integrated with Google Maps, providing even more convenience for the potential consumer. These new features were impeccably timed as the pandemic continues to rage on and the holiday season is approaching, and retailers are embracing these new innovations to help them meet sales targets.

Google’s continued focus on seamless integration has helped the tech giant remain at the forefront of innovation, further solidifying its leading position in the tech world. The debate continues as to whether Google has monopoly power, but there is no doubt that it provides great services to its customers.

Friday, November 27, 2020

YouTube to offer audio-only ads

Source: https://blog.google/products/ads-commerce/youtube-music-audio-ads


YouTube is launching a new audio-only ads, targeting users primarily listening to podcasts and music on background. Advertisers will have an ability to target users based on music genre (e.g., rock, rap, pop, etc.) they listen, and their interests (e.g., motivational, "gym music", etc.). YouTube claims that during their alpha trials 75% of audio ads resulted in a significant increase in brand awareness of advertisers.

I think these news are particularly worrisome for such audio and podcast streaming services as Spotify and Pandora, both of which generate generate substantial ads revenues of $0.7bn and 1.2bn per year through audio ads, since YouTube's impressive trial results and likely an aggressive expansion into audio-only ads clearly intensifies its competition against them. 

However, it is not only music and podcast streaming services who should worry but all marketing platforms. Considering vast amount of data Google already possesses and the recent news of YouTube incorporating shopping functionality (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-10-09/google-tries-to-turn-youtube-into-a-major-shopping-destination), Google has high chances of becoming the one-stop advertisement platform in future

Black Friday is here - and it's completely different

 https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/11/27/black-friday-holiday-shopping/


The article summarizes how the pandemic has changed Black Friday from lining up outside in the cold on Thanksgiving night to mainly online. Stores like Wal-Mart, Best Buy, Target, and Macy's that typically have huge crowds waiting for the doors to open are relatively empty this Friday morning. Buy online, pick up in store is more popular than ever before. But many stores have invested in their eCommerce technology and sites to capitalize off of the virus restrictions.

With more stores optimizing their online  channel, customers are receiving incredibly large numbers of email ads. Even Thanksgiving evening, I received hundreds of emails from stores having sales on Black Friday, or that had started holiday sales even earlier. Stores must be creative in their digital marketing - they must be able to stand out amongst the droves of emails consumers have been receiving all week. I've seen some stores have sign-ups for early access, or open sales early for their most loyal customers. Many brands are utilizing their Instagram to build hype around drops of new products or promotions. Even companies that do not typically have sales (like Everlane) are discounting products this year. 

Despite the struggle of many department stores and brands that have gone out of business this year, smaller DTC brands are doing well - and proving themselves fierce competition. There are so many lists of black owned brands and other local, smaller brands to support this year. These smaller, DTC brands are often better at social media than the large brands because they are nimble, and can adapt quickly to always stay culturally relevant. These small brands are constantly interacting with their followers, and able to gauge what to restock, or discount in their limited inventory. Hopefully Black Friday will help many of the up and coming brands stay afloat throughout the continuing pandemic. 

Football Clubs Can Market Too

As a big soccer fan, and especially a big fan of the Premier League, it's always good to see English clubs make new efforts in digital to market their team and expand their reach. In one particular case, Chelsea FC recognized that their stadium could only accommodate 42,000 people, a tiny fraction of their global fan base. Their challenge: to improve the match day experience for those fans that were not able to be there in person. The metrics they set to validate their goal were 1 million MAU and at least the 4th most downloaded football app in the world.

Gaining and keeping engagement was key - they had to analyze their mobile data, create personas to design the app experience, and then use paid media and push marketing to tempt less active target fans with relevant content. Then using these fanbase estimates, were able to calculate a cost-per-monthly-active-user number, and bump it up against the value of users continually engaging with the app over a longer period of time (ads, in-app spend, gear purchases, etc.).

The club's meticulous marketing approach worked - within six months of launch it met its goals, becoming the fourth most popular football app overall, and winning the 2020 Marketing Week Masters award for mobile. It shows what can be done when a business identifies a customer base that is mostly stagnant, and designs a concentrated marketing effort to target them and win their engagement.

https://www.marketingweek.com/masters-awards-chelsea-increased-fan-loyalty/

Thursday, November 26, 2020

Most effective marketing channels for fintech startup launch

Our startup on November 16th publicly launched our product (www.jenova.ai). We used multiple social media channels to promote our launch, including Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, and WeChat. We tracked the visits to our website on Google Analytics.

In the week of November 16th, there were 662 new visitors to our website. Nearly 90% of the new visitors came from direct URL visit or organic Google search, 4.2% came from Facebook, 3.3% came from LinkedIn, and 2.0% came from Instagram. 

Even though we do not have precise methods to measure the casual relationship between promotions on each social media channel and new visitors, nor can we effectively measure the number of impressions and the % of impressions that converted to website visits, we are able to get a good sense of how effective each social media channel is by monitoring the number of new visitors after each promotion was posted online, with the peak number of new visits somewhere between 20 minutes to 90 minutes after the promotion was posted. 

Using this crude method, we determined that Facebook posts and Instagram posts were ineffective in driving website visits; this is likely due to the relatively low number of followers we possess on those two platforms. We also determined that LinkedIn was extremely ineffective in driving traffic, despite the high number of impressions, connections, and social shares. By far the most effective channel for driving traffic was through WeChat social circle share feature, which accounted for the vast majority of the 90% direct URL visits and google searches.