Most top retailers in mobile commerce are offering mobile site and app designs and promotions consistent with the designs and offers on their desktop e-commerce sites, according to a new study by Internet Retailer editors of the top 100 merchants in the recently published 2014
Internet Retailer Mobile 500. E-commerce and m-commerce chiefs say it is important to provide consistent and seamless shopping across digital channels because customers expect it.
However, as shoppers spend an increasing amount of time and money on mobile, some top mobile merchants are giving their customers using smartphones and tablets exclusive offers, and are using uniquely mobile technologies such as text messages and app push notifications to give mobile shoppers an edge.
Groupon, HSN Inc., JackThreads.com, RueLaLa.com and Target Corp. all tell Internet Retailer that the majority of their traffic Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday came from mobile devices, and web-only retailers Groupon, JackThreads.com and RueLaLa.com report the majority of their holiday weekend sales were mobile. Groupon Goods is No. 5 in the
Internet Retailer Mobile 500, HSN No. 9, JackThreads.com No. 88, RueLaLa.com No. 11 and Target No. 36.
All five merchants say it is very important that shopping on mobile commerce web sites and apps mirror shopping on PC web sites, even during the holiday season.
"We want all of our members to experience Rue La La seamlessly across devices," says Gerry McGoldrick, vice president of marketing and mobile chief at members-only e-retailer RueLaLa.com. "During the busy holiday season, we aim to keep things simple and streamlined for our members, and we believe the key to that is a seamless, consistent, familiar experience. Our members experience Rue La La from different touch-points—iPhone, iPad, Android, apps, desktops—and we want them to be able to pick up where they left off from any device."
This is indeed a key consideration for retailers. Google Inc. research shows that 85% of online shoppers start shopping on one device and finish on another.
"By and large the offerings and marketing that Target has on its desktop web site and in stores are consistent on mobile," a Target spokesman says. "We want the mobile experience to feel connected and seamless for guests, who are increasingly moving between various channels."
Groupon does keep design and offers consistent between e-commerce and m-commerce. However, it made one enormous change for Thanksgiving weekend—on the home pages of its sites and home screens of its apps, it replaced daily deals (discount vouchers that are routinely featured first and foremost) with Groupon Goods, merchandise that's more gift-oriented, the merchant says.
Groupon has presented some mobile-only holiday offers, including a $10 Target gift card for $6 in select markets. The merchant also is sending holiday-themed push notifications through its apps, which have been downloaded more than 60 million times, Groupon says. Push alerts, for example, have included "Skip the lines! Get Black Friday doorbuster deals on Groupon. Shop now!" and "Want great Cyber Monday deals? Check Groupon first. Shop now!"
RueLaLa.com also is sending app users
push notifications during the holidays. "You Heard It Here First" push messages notify app users of time-sensitive sales before all Rue La La members are notified via e-mail. HSN Inc. sent app push notifications and text messages notifying mobile shoppers of exclusive pre-Black Friday sales.
Some top 100 mobile retailers that strive to keep consistent, familiar designs and offers across PC and mobile channels do tweak their mobile sites and apps to better serve consumers on smaller screens. Tory Burch LLC, No. 70 in the Internet Retailer Mobile 500, has created a commerce site using responsive web design, which enables retailers to build a single site with a single code base and single set of web content that renders to fit the size of a screen. On larger screens, a hero image highlighting “Tory’s Gift Guide” includes an embedded box with a Shop Now button that breaks out to include subordinate links such as Most Wanted Gifts, Gifts by Category and Gifts by Price. When the site is viewed on a smartphone, only the Shop Now button is featured; that leads to easy-to-tap images that help mobile shoppers more easily drill down.
Timed to coincide with the start of holiday shopping, ShopHQ (formerly ShopNBC.com) last month unveiled mobile apps for iPad and Android tablets. Like most other top mobile retailers, ShopHQ believes in consistency between e-commerce and m-commerce. However, it does offer mobile shoppers a bonus. When mobile shoppers use the Watch Now feature to view the ShopHQ television network live feed on their devices, they are presented with content related to what's on the air, including some enhanced content not available on the desktop.
"We do not offer special pricing or promotion strategies by channel or platform. By providing our customers the same experience, regardless of how they interact with us, we are able to offer a consistent shopping experience that does not discriminate by channel of engagement," says Tom Kraus, vice president of e-commerce at ShopHQ, No. 52 in the Mobile 500. "We are expecting huge mobile growth this holiday season as our customers continue to adopt and expand their utilization of mobile as an engagement and order channel. That growth, especially in tablets, will push mobile to new levels as we enter the first half of 2014."
Target has been giving mobile commerce some special attention this holiday season. Target developed two mobile-optimized Facebook applications, one that offered Black Friday ad leaks and one that will award mobile shoppers with gift cards this month. The Target mobile shopping app features holiday mobile coupons, which customers use by having a cashier in-store scan their phones at checkout.
HSN is betting big on mobile commerce this holiday season, says Edward Deutscher, operating vice president, digital technology. Mobile sales were strong leading into the holidays, up 57% in the third quarter, year over year, Deutscher says. By mid-September, HSN had eclipsed the $167 million in mobile sales it generated for all of 2012, he adds.
"We have invested a lot in optimizing all of our digital initiatives mobile-first, ensuring that the experience is seamless across all channels," says Deutscher, keeping with the consistent and familiar approach. HSN has gone
mobile-first, a design scheme where a retailer creates sites and apps for smartphones first, and then carries the design up to tablets and then desktops, making some refinements for the larger screens along the way.
HSN is offering a mobile coupon ($20 off $40) to new customers throughout the holiday season. Mobile customers can win prizes for watching featured video content. And the merchant offers a mobile-exclusive sweepstakes where shoppers can win a $3,000 HSN shopping spree; HSN is promoting the sweepstakes through mobile display ads.
Unlike HSN, some top mobile retailers have not gone the mobile-first route. Foot Locker Inc., No. 27 in the Mobile 500, and Rakuten.com Shopping, No. 28, are not doing anything unusual for mobile for the holidays, but both offer m-commerce sites for smartphones that are more streamlined than their desktop sites. Foot Locker's mobile site home page, for example, features a primary image that says, "Sale/Limited Time Only," and below is a list of best sellers. A site search box tops the page. The PC site home page, though, is loaded with images and videos of athletes and shoes.
Similarly, Rakuten.com Shopping's mobile site is quite uncluttered, with a carousel of images and offers also found on the PC site. Stacked vertically below the carousel are bars for Shop By Department, Deals, Account, and Your Orders.
While some top mobile retailers have special offers or features for mobile shoppers this holiday season, most are forging a mobile channel that mirrors the desktop channel to give their customers consistency in digital shopping.
"The sales and offers our customers will see on mobile will be similar to the ones available on desktop," says Jason Ross, founder and CEO of
JackThreads.com. "We're focused on making sure mobile customers can find all of the great offerings they'd find on the web while they travel during the holidays and are away from their desktop computers."